Home News OFFICIAL RESPONSE BY THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL ON LSL ISSUE

OFFICIAL RESPONSE BY THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL ON LSL ISSUE

137
0
Sponsored Advertisement

OFFICIAL RESPONSE BY THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL,  GABRIEL SURI, TO ALLEGATIONS OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST RELATING TO THE LSL SETTLEMENT

I wish to respond to allegations made against me by the Leader of the Opposition, Hon. Manasseh Sogavare, former Attorney-General John Muria Jr and former Commissioner of Lands Alan McNeil concerning my involvement in resolving the outstanding legal disputes between the Solomon Islands Government (SIG) and Levers Solomon Limited (LSL).

I categorically reject the allegations of conflict of interest. The allegations misrepresent the circumstances surrounding my involvement, the legal history of the LSL dispute and the responsibilities I carried out as Attorney-General.

1. My Previous Professional Relationship with LSL and RIPEL

Sponsored Advertisement

I ceased acting for LSL in 2017; I had no continuing professional relationship with LSL; I had no financial interest in LSL; I was acting solely for SIG as Attorney General; the Government’s policy had already been determined by Cabinet and the Prime Minister; and the settlement reflected existing court orders and Government objectives.

My involvement in the present matter was undertaken strictly in my capacity as Attorney-General and pursuant to the direction of the Prime Minister to find a resolution to two outstanding cases which the former Attorney-General, John Muria Jr, had lost in the High Court. These cases had become an impediment to the GREAT Coalition Government’s implementation of its published policies, particularly the development of the RIPEL coconut plantation in Russell Islands into a National Coconut Processing Industry hub.

There was therefore a clear Government policy and public interest basis for seeking a resolution to the disputes.

2. The Prime Minister’s Direction and Discussions with LSL

Former Commissioner of Lands, Alan McNeil, was fully aware of the direction given by the Prime Minister, as both of us attended a meeting convened by the Prime Minister on this matter.

Subsequently, the Government team met with representatives of LSL, including Patrick Wong, John Kapentana and LSL’s overseas counsel, Geoffrey McDonald. The Government team comprised myself, Alan McNeil and other officials.

The purpose of these discussions was to explore the most appropriate and cost-effective option available to the Government to resolve the land issues, whether through a Deed of Company Arrangement (DoCA) or direct purchase.

file 00000000e24481fab32b559972348377

I made it clear that the Government’s preference was to pursue an option that would be less costly and less problematic, while ensuring that the State acquired 100 per cent ownership of the lands.

At that meeting, Patrick Wong acknowledged that direct purchase would be the legally cleanest option. He explained that it would avoid the complications associated with a DoCA, court-mandated obligations, creditor and litigation risks, as well as potential public perception issues.

These discussions demonstrate that the Government was exploring options in the interests of the State and not acting to advance the private interests of any individual or company.

3. The SBD $64,678,871.78 and Existing High Court Orders

I reject any suggestion that I personally determined or created the amount of SBD $64,678,871.78 payable to LSL.

This amount was approved and ordered by the High Court on 16 August 2022, following an application made by LSL’s counsel, Alice Willy. It represented an increase from the $50 million previously agreed upon by the Sogavare-led DCGA in 2017.

Under the consent orders and subsequent judgment of the High Court delivered on 16 August 2022, the former DCGA Government had already facilitated payments to LSL totalling SBD $32 million. This comprised SBD $20 million paid on 15 September 2022 and a further SBD $12 million paid on 10 November 2023.

On 29 November 2025, the Court granted an enforcement order requiring the Government to pay the SBD $64,678,871.78.

It is important to understand that these court orders and the underlying financial obligations existed before my involvement in seeking an out-of-court resolution.

As Attorney-General and an officer of the Court, I have a professional and legal duty to ensure that the Government respects and complies with court orders. Compliance with the orders of the Court cannot reasonably be characterised as a conflict of interest.

4. My Involvement in the Forfeiture and Compulsory Acquisition Cases

For the avoidance of doubt, I was not involved in the original Forfeiture and Compulsory Acquisition cases during the High Court proceedings. I never represented LSL in either of those proceedings, at any stage before or during the High Court hearings.

My personal involvement was limited to efforts to settle the Forfeiture and Compulsory Acquisition disputes out of court, following the direction of the Prime Minister.

I subsequently met with the lawyers within the Attorney-General’s Chambers who had been involved in the cases to discuss the strength of the appeals lodged during the tenure of the former Attorney-General.

I was advised by junior counsel that the appeals had merits and approximately a 50 per cent prospect of success. However, having considered the legal position and the circumstances of the cases, I formed the view that the appeals were weak and unsustainable in law. I therefore instructed that the appeals be abandoned.

That decision was made in my professional assessment of the Government’s legal position and the risks associated with continuing the litigation.

5. The Benefits of the Consent Order to the State

Following the decision to abandon the appeals, a Consent Order was developed as the basis for negotiations between the parties and was eventually signed.

The Consent Order provided important benefits and protections for the Solomon Islands Government.

First, it provided that the SBD $64,678,871.78 would be frozen, preventing the amount from increasing further, and established a schedule of payment to finally settle the outstanding amount.

Second, upon payment, the State would acquire Hell’s Point, an asset of significant strategic importance to the Solomon Islands Government, particularly the Royal Solomon Islands Police Force.

Third, the Consent Order provided that LSL would not pursue further claims for damages and costs against the State. This was significant because LSL’s overseas counsel had indicated that the company might pursue a further claim of approximately SBD $35 million against the Government following the Court of Appeal proceedings.

These provisions were important considerations in determining whether the settlement was in the best interests of the State.

BulkYour one stop shop 3

The amount payable to LSL is also subject to tax. This arrangement was addressed through a separate Consent Order in the tax matter following discussions with the Commissioner of Inland Revenue.

6. The Way Forward

The settlement must be understood within the broader objective of resolving longstanding land disputes and removing legal obstacles to national development.

The Government must be able to pursue practical and legally sound solutions to land issues, whether through direct purchase or a properly negotiated DoCA arrangement.

The objective is to protect the interests of the State, minimise further financial and legal exposure, secure important national assets and create opportunities for productive economic development.

I therefore reject the allegations of conflict of interest made against me. My previous professional relationship with LSL and RIPEL ended in 2017. I did not represent LSL in the original High Court proceedings, and my subsequent involvement was undertaken in my official capacity as Attorney-General, following the Prime Minister’s direction and in the interests of resolving the disputes.

I have discharged my responsibilities based on my understanding of the law, my professional assessment of the Government’s legal position and my duty to protect the interests of the Solomon Islands Government.

GABRIEL SURI
ATTORNEY-GENERAL
SOLOMON ISLANDS

What you think?

Sponsored Advertisement